Find out when limited liability can fail and how to avoid it.
Calculate the quote
Gabriele Rossi
Being the sole shareholder of a Società a responsabilità limitata (or S.r.l. – Italian limited) offers advantages in terms of flexibility and asset protection, but it also hides pitfalls that may jeopardize both the business and personal wealth. This article explores the main legal, fiscal, and administrative risks a sole shareholder may face, explaining why limited liability is not always guaranteed. It also outlines effective asset protection strategies, such as implementing proper organizational structures and using legal instruments like trusts, to shield personal property from potential creditor actions. For those looking to safeguard their assets and manage their business with greater security, this guide highlights essential precautions and common mistakes to avoid.
An S.r.l. unipersonale (a single-member Italian limited liability company) offers a significant advantage to the sole shareholder: the separation between company assets and personal assets. In case of financial difficulties, the shareholder is liable only up to the amount of capital contributed, thereby protecting personal wealth from creditors.
However, this protection is not absolute. The “veil” of limited liability can be lifted in certain circumstances, exposing the sole shareholder to personal liability. This may occur in cases of:
If the sole shareholder treats company assets as personal property, disregarding transparency and separation rules, they may lose the benefit of limited liability and become personally liable for company debts.
But what are the actual risks a sole shareholder may face when managing an S.r.l.? Let’s explore that in the next section.
While being the sole shareholder of an S.r.l. offers significant advantages, it also entails serious responsibilities that should not be underestimated. If the company is not managed with due diligence and transparency, the sole shareholder may face personal liability under several profiles.
One of the main risks concerns administrative and criminal liability. If the sole shareholder also serves as the director, they are legally required to manage the company properly and in the best interests of the business. Fraudulent or negligent behavior may lead to severe penalties, including fines and imprisonment. For instance, fraudulent bankruptcy is a serious offense that can arise from actions such as misappropriation of company assets or falsification of accounts.
Tax and accounting management is another high-risk area. Failing to pay VAT exceeding €250,000 is considered a criminal offense under Italian law and may result in serious legal consequences. Inaccurate bookkeeping or unrecorded transactions can attract the attention of the Guardia di Finanza (Italian financial police), leading to audits and sanctions.
Further risks stem from errors in capital contributions and legal disclosure requirements related to single-member S.r.l.s. If the shareholder fails to comply with Articles 2462, 2463, 2470 and 2478 of the Italian Civil Code, they may lose limited liability protection and become personally liable for corporate debts. This can occur, for example, when contributions are not correctly made or when the company fails to properly declare its single-member status.
To mitigate these risks, the sole shareholder must manage the company with care and adopt appropriate protective measures. One of the most effective tools for shielding personal assets is the trust.
While limited liability in a single-member S.r.l. provides important protection, it is not always sufficient. In high-risk situations, one of the most effective tools for protecting personal wealth is the trust.
A trust is a legal instrument of Anglo-Saxon origin that allows an individual (the settlor) to transfer assets to a trustee, who manages them for the benefit of one or more beneficiaries. The key advantage of a trust lies in its asset segregation effect: the assets placed into a trust are separated from both the settlor’s and the trustee’s personal assets, making them inaccessible to creditors in case of financial distress or enforcement actions.
However, to be effective, the timing of the trust’s establishment is crucial. If assets are transferred to the trust during a period of financial instability or pending insolvency, creditors may challenge the transaction through a revocatory action, potentially nullifying the protective effect.
In Italy, trusts are not governed by a specific national law but are recognized and applied under the Hague Convention of 1985, ratified by Law No. 364/1989. Trusts are thus regulated through well-established practices and case law. To avoid legal disputes and ensure the validity of the trust, it is essential to draft the trust deed carefully, clearly stating the purpose and complying with all formal requirements.
Beyond trusts, other strategies can be employed to protect a sole shareholder’s assets and minimize risks. These will be discussed in the next section.
For the sole shareholder of an S.r.l., limited liability is a crucial safeguard—but not enough on its own. The key to protecting personal assets and reducing business vulnerabilities lies in adopting a preventive and strategic approach.
First and foremost, the company must be managed with the utmost diligence, ensuring the implementation of appropriate organizational, administrative, and accounting structures as required by Article 2086 of the Italian Civil Code. This article mandates that the director (often the sole shareholder in single-member S.r.l.s) establish a management system capable of promptly detecting financial distress and ensuring business continuity. Failure to do so may result in serious personal liability, as highlighted in the article “The Liability of Directors for Lack of Adequate Organizational Structures” by P. Lo Monaco Dominguez.
Transparent documentation is equally essential. All significant operations—from contracts to capital contributions and shareholders’ resolutions—must be clearly recorded and formalized. A meticulous approach to documentation not only prevents disputes but can be critical in legal proceedings or tax audits.
In high-risk situations, additional asset protection tools may be considered. If properly structured and established in a timely manner, a trust remains one of the most effective solutions for separating personal and corporate assets. However, its use requires careful planning and the support of skilled professionals to ensure validity and avoid challenges from creditors.
The position of a sole shareholder should be seen not only as a business opportunity but also as a responsibility that demands careful management. Only by combining sound governance, qualified legal advice, and appropriate legal tools is it possible to protect personal wealth and ensure long-term business sustainability.
Gabriele Rossi
